Sharon Cairns Mann:  award-winning author
  • Home
  • Fiction
  • Nonfiction
  • Awards
  • Blog: A Good Read
  • FOR SALE: Aflac Duck Collection
  • Contact & Sign Up
  • Product

Blog Post #17:  How’s that for Due Process?

9/27/2016

0 Comments

 
"The board is looking for easy headlines and scapegoats." Dan Foster
The Administrative Law Judge signed his decision on September 14, 2007 and sent it to the attorneys on September 24, and I’m sure we heard about it fairly quickly thereafter. (Click here to read the decision.)
 
As you may recall, the Board of the Division of Real Estate had filed an emergency motion against Julie on June 1, stating that they found “that the health, safety, and welfare imperatively requires emergency action as a result of Respondent’s conduct.” (Seriously, Dear Reader, was your health, safety, or welfare threatened by a real estate appraiser doing appraisals in rural areas?) So, without benefit of due process, they had suspended Julie’s license before the hearing.  Their motion included many trumped up “counts,” “allegations,” and “aggravating factors.” They asked the judge that her license be revoked and that she be fined $500 for each offense (it’s unclear what they consider an “offense” in their motion).
 
The ALJ recapped his understanding (still with much confusion about annexation and utilities), and concluded that Julie had made errors, but “the evidence is not sufficient to prove that her errors were willful or that her valuation of the property was intentionally inflated.  The ALJ therefore concludes that the revocation of the Respondent’s license is not appropriate, but that her appraiser’s license be suspended for six months with credit given for the period her license has been under summary suspension (approximately three months at that time). Respondent’s license shall also be put on probation for three years. In addition Respondent shall be fined $500.”
 
We were happy and relieved for Julie, and we felt vindicated ourselves that all this nonsense about fraud, collusion and abuse was now behind us.

Toll Goes Against Judge’s Order

Unfortunately, Erin Toll had other plans for Julie.  We found out in early December that Toll had the Division of Real Estate go against the judge’s order, reduced Julie’s license to the lowest level possible, and fined her $10,000.  "This stipulated agreement is good for the community because if we simply revoked her license, she can reapply in two years," said Erin Toll, director of the state's Division of Real Estate. "Revocations are not permanent."  (See Denver Post article, below.)

In other words, Toll was trying to inflict the most harm possible on Julie. How’s that for due process?
O'Gorman's attorney, Dan Foster, said that while the judge found some violations, they were not considered willful.

"All the allegations of fraud that were out there in the media and how she was doing fraudulent appraisals were proven wrong, and we still lose," Foster said. "I think they're going to use her as their poster child and do whatever they can to show that they're getting tough on bad appraisers. The board is looking for easy headlines and scapegoats."
​

It’s a sad outcome when truth is not upheld, and justice is not delivered.  
© Sharon Cairns Mann
ogorman.decision.judge.pdf
File Size: 961 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

denver_post.12.06.07.appraiser_fined.pdf
File Size: 82 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Hi! Welcome to this blog!   I'm a professional writer and award-winning author. I didn't really want to write this blog, but I also believe that the story of the huge conservation easement fiasco in Colorado has not yet been adequately told. So here it is!

    It's so long, I've had to serialize it, so please note that you have to START with Blog Post #1 (June 28, 2016) for the story to make sense!  So, if you're new to the blog, please go back to the beginning and start there.   

    New Post Notifications 
    ​The best way to hear about each my new blog posts on Swindled is to just go to my Public Facebook Page at
    Sharon Cairns Mann Writer
    and hit the "Like" button in the cover photo at the top. Every time I do a new blog post here, I'll announce it there, so it should keep you up-to-date. 

    But if you are interested in free writing tips and coaching, please subscribe to "Writerly News" by clicking the button below.

    Subscribe to "Writerly News"

    Archives

    April 2018
    April 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.